Merge "Limit the number of cached languages in MessageCache via MapCacheLRU"
[lhc/web/wiklou.git] / includes / libs / rdbms / loadbalancer / ILoadBalancer.php
1 <?php
2 /**
3 * Database load balancing interface
4 *
5 * This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify
6 * it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by
7 * the Free Software Foundation; either version 2 of the License, or
8 * (at your option) any later version.
9 *
10 * This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
11 * but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
12 * MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the
13 * GNU General Public License for more details.
14 *
15 * You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License along
16 * with this program; if not, write to the Free Software Foundation, Inc.,
17 * 51 Franklin Street, Fifth Floor, Boston, MA 02110-1301, USA.
18 * http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/gpl.html
19 *
20 * @file
21 * @ingroup Database
22 */
23 namespace Wikimedia\Rdbms;
24
25 use Exception;
26 use InvalidArgumentException;
27
28 /**
29 * Database cluster connection, tracking, load balancing, and transaction manager interface
30 *
31 * A "cluster" is considered to be one master database and zero or more replica databases.
32 * Typically, the replica DBs replicate from the master asynchronously. The first node in the
33 * "servers" configuration array is always considered the "master". However, this class can still
34 * be used when all or some of the "replica" DBs are multi-master peers of the master or even
35 * when all the DBs are non-replicating clones of each other holding read-only data. Thus, the
36 * role of "master" is in some cases merely nominal.
37 *
38 * By default, each DB server uses DBO_DEFAULT for its 'flags' setting, unless explicitly set
39 * otherwise in configuration. DBO_DEFAULT behavior depends on whether 'cliMode' is set:
40 * - In CLI mode, the flag has no effect with regards to LoadBalancer.
41 * - In non-CLI mode, the flag causes implicit transactions to be used; the first query on
42 * a database starts a transaction on that database. The transactions are meant to remain
43 * pending until either commitMasterChanges() or rollbackMasterChanges() is called. The
44 * application must have some point where it calls commitMasterChanges() near the end of
45 * the PHP request.
46 * Every iteration of beginMasterChanges()/commitMasterChanges() is called a "transaction round".
47 * Rounds are useful on the master DB connections because they make single-DB (and by and large
48 * multi-DB) updates in web requests all-or-nothing. Also, transactions on replica DBs are useful
49 * when REPEATABLE-READ or SERIALIZABLE isolation is used because all foriegn keys and constraints
50 * hold across separate queries in the DB transaction since the data appears within a consistent
51 * point-in-time snapshot.
52 *
53 * The typical caller will use LoadBalancer::getConnection( DB_* ) to yield a live database
54 * connection handle. The choice of which DB server to use is based on pre-defined loads for
55 * weighted random selection, adjustments thereof by LoadMonitor, and the amount of replication
56 * lag on each DB server. Lag checks might cause problems in certain setups, so they should be
57 * tuned in the server configuration maps as follows:
58 * - Master + N Replica(s): set 'max lag' to an appropriate threshold for avoiding any database
59 * lagged by this much or more. If all DBs are this lagged, then the load balancer considers
60 * the cluster to be read-only.
61 * - Galera Cluster: Seconds_Behind_Master will be 0, so there probably is nothing to tune.
62 * Note that lag is still possible depending on how wsrep-sync-wait is set server-side.
63 * - Read-only archive clones: set 'is static' in the server configuration maps. This will
64 * treat all such DBs as having 0 lag.
65 * - SQL load balancing proxy: any proxy should handle lag checks on its own, so the 'max lag'
66 * parameter should probably be set to INF in the server configuration maps. This will make
67 * the load balancer ignore whatever it detects as the lag of the logical replica is (which
68 * would probably just randomly bounce around).
69 *
70 * If using a SQL proxy service, it would probably be best to have two proxy hosts for the
71 * load balancer to talk to. One would be the 'host' of the master server entry and another for
72 * the (logical) replica server entry. The proxy could map the load balancer's "replica" DB to
73 * any number of physical replica DBs.
74 *
75 * @since 1.28
76 * @ingroup Database
77 */
78 interface ILoadBalancer {
79 /** @var int Request a replica DB connection */
80 const DB_REPLICA = -1;
81 /** @var int Request a master DB connection */
82 const DB_MASTER = -2;
83
84 /** @var string Domain specifier when no specific database needs to be selected */
85 const DOMAIN_ANY = '';
86
87 /** @var int DB handle should have DBO_TRX disabled and the caller will leave it as such */
88 const CONN_TRX_AUTOCOMMIT = 1;
89
90 /** @var string Manager of ILoadBalancer instances is running post-commit callbacks */
91 const STAGE_POSTCOMMIT_CALLBACKS = 'stage-postcommit-callbacks';
92 /** @var string Manager of ILoadBalancer instances is running post-rollback callbacks */
93 const STAGE_POSTROLLBACK_CALLBACKS = 'stage-postrollback-callbacks';
94
95 /**
96 * Construct a manager of IDatabase connection objects
97 *
98 * @param array $params Parameter map with keys:
99 * - servers : Required. Array of server info structures.
100 * - localDomain: A DatabaseDomain or domain ID string.
101 * - loadMonitor : Name of a class used to fetch server lag and load.
102 * - readOnlyReason : Reason the master DB is read-only if so [optional]
103 * - waitTimeout : Maximum time to wait for replicas for consistency [optional]
104 * - maxLag: Avoid replica DB servers with more lag than this [optional]
105 * - srvCache : BagOStuff object for server cache [optional]
106 * - wanCache : WANObjectCache object [optional]
107 * - chronologyCallback: Callback to run before the first connection attempt [optional]
108 * - hostname : The name of the current server [optional]
109 * - cliMode: Whether the execution context is a CLI script. [optional]
110 * - profiler : Class name or instance with profileIn()/profileOut() methods. [optional]
111 * - trxProfiler: TransactionProfiler instance. [optional]
112 * - replLogger: PSR-3 logger instance. [optional]
113 * - connLogger: PSR-3 logger instance. [optional]
114 * - queryLogger: PSR-3 logger instance. [optional]
115 * - perfLogger: PSR-3 logger instance. [optional]
116 * - errorLogger : Callback that takes an Exception and logs it. [optional]
117 * - deprecationLogger: Callback to log a deprecation warning. [optional]
118 * - roundStage: STAGE_POSTCOMMIT_* class constant; for internal use [optional]
119 * @throws InvalidArgumentException
120 */
121 public function __construct( array $params );
122
123 /**
124 * Get the index of the reader connection, which may be a replica DB
125 *
126 * This takes into account load ratios and lag times. It should
127 * always return a consistent index during a given invocation.
128 *
129 * Side effect: opens connections to databases
130 * @param string|bool $group Query group, or false for the generic reader
131 * @param string|bool $domain Domain ID, or false for the current domain
132 * @throws DBError
133 * @return bool|int|string
134 */
135 public function getReaderIndex( $group = false, $domain = false );
136
137 /**
138 * Set the master wait position
139 *
140 * If a DB_REPLICA connection has been opened already, then wait immediately.
141 * Otherwise sets a variable telling it to wait if such a connection is opened.
142 *
143 * This only applies to connections to the generic replica DB for this request.
144 * If a timeout happens when waiting, then getLaggedReplicaMode()/laggedReplicaUsed()
145 * will return true.
146 *
147 * @param DBMasterPos|bool $pos Master position or false
148 */
149 public function waitFor( $pos );
150
151 /**
152 * Set the master wait position and wait for a "generic" replica DB to catch up to it
153 *
154 * This can be used a faster proxy for waitForAll()
155 *
156 * @param DBMasterPos|bool $pos Master position or false
157 * @param int $timeout Max seconds to wait; default is mWaitTimeout
158 * @return bool Success (able to connect and no timeouts reached)
159 */
160 public function waitForOne( $pos, $timeout = null );
161
162 /**
163 * Set the master wait position and wait for ALL replica DBs to catch up to it
164 *
165 * @param DBMasterPos|bool $pos Master position or false
166 * @param int $timeout Max seconds to wait; default is mWaitTimeout
167 * @return bool Success (able to connect and no timeouts reached)
168 */
169 public function waitForAll( $pos, $timeout = null );
170
171 /**
172 * Get any open connection to a given server index, local or foreign
173 *
174 * Use CONN_TRX_AUTOCOMMIT to only look for connections opened with that flag
175 *
176 * @param int $i Server index or DB_MASTER/DB_REPLICA
177 * @param int $flags Bitfield of CONN_* class constants
178 * @return Database|bool False if no such connection is open
179 */
180 public function getAnyOpenConnection( $i, $flags = 0 );
181
182 /**
183 * Get a connection handle by server index
184 *
185 * The CONN_TRX_AUTOCOMMIT flag is ignored for databases with ATTR_DB_LEVEL_LOCKING
186 * (e.g. sqlite) in order to avoid deadlocks. ILoadBalancer::getServerAttributes()
187 * can be used to check such flags beforehand.
188 *
189 * If the caller uses $domain or sets CONN_TRX_AUTOCOMMIT in $flags, then it must also
190 * call ILoadBalancer::reuseConnection() on the handle when finished using it.
191 * In all other cases, this is not necessary, though not harmful either.
192 *
193 * @param int $i Server index (overrides $groups) or DB_MASTER/DB_REPLICA
194 * @param array|string|bool $groups Query group(s), or false for the generic reader
195 * @param string|bool $domain Domain ID, or false for the current domain
196 * @param int $flags Bitfield of CONN_* class constants
197 *
198 * @note This method throws DBAccessError if ILoadBalancer::disable() was called
199 *
200 * @throws DBError
201 * @return Database
202 */
203 public function getConnection( $i, $groups = [], $domain = false, $flags = 0 );
204
205 /**
206 * Mark a foreign connection as being available for reuse under a different DB domain
207 *
208 * This mechanism is reference-counted, and must be called the same number of times
209 * as getConnection() to work.
210 *
211 * @param IDatabase $conn
212 * @throws InvalidArgumentException
213 */
214 public function reuseConnection( IDatabase $conn );
215
216 /**
217 * Get a database connection handle reference
218 *
219 * The handle's methods simply wrap those of a Database handle
220 *
221 * The CONN_TRX_AUTOCOMMIT flag is ignored for databases with ATTR_DB_LEVEL_LOCKING
222 * (e.g. sqlite) in order to avoid deadlocks. ILoadBalancer::getServerAttributes()
223 * can be used to check such flags beforehand.
224 *
225 * @see ILoadBalancer::getConnection() for parameter information
226 *
227 * @param int $i Server index or DB_MASTER/DB_REPLICA
228 * @param array|string|bool $groups Query group(s), or false for the generic reader
229 * @param string|bool $domain Domain ID, or false for the current domain
230 * @param int $flags Bitfield of CONN_* class constants (e.g. CONN_TRX_AUTOCOMMIT)
231 * @return DBConnRef
232 */
233 public function getConnectionRef( $i, $groups = [], $domain = false, $flags = 0 );
234
235 /**
236 * Get a database connection handle reference without connecting yet
237 *
238 * The handle's methods simply wrap those of a Database handle
239 *
240 * The CONN_TRX_AUTOCOMMIT flag is ignored for databases with ATTR_DB_LEVEL_LOCKING
241 * (e.g. sqlite) in order to avoid deadlocks. ILoadBalancer::getServerAttributes()
242 * can be used to check such flags beforehand.
243 *
244 * @see ILoadBalancer::getConnection() for parameter information
245 *
246 * @param int $i Server index or DB_MASTER/DB_REPLICA
247 * @param array|string|bool $groups Query group(s), or false for the generic reader
248 * @param string|bool $domain Domain ID, or false for the current domain
249 * @param int $flags Bitfield of CONN_* class constants (e.g. CONN_TRX_AUTOCOMMIT)
250 * @return DBConnRef
251 */
252 public function getLazyConnectionRef( $i, $groups = [], $domain = false, $flags = 0 );
253
254 /**
255 * Get a maintenance database connection handle reference for migrations and schema changes
256 *
257 * The handle's methods simply wrap those of a Database handle
258 *
259 * The CONN_TRX_AUTOCOMMIT flag is ignored for databases with ATTR_DB_LEVEL_LOCKING
260 * (e.g. sqlite) in order to avoid deadlocks. ILoadBalancer::getServerAttributes()
261 * can be used to check such flags beforehand.
262 *
263 * @see ILoadBalancer::getConnection() for parameter information
264 *
265 * @param int $db Server index or DB_MASTER/DB_REPLICA
266 * @param array|string|bool $groups Query group(s), or false for the generic reader
267 * @param string|bool $domain Domain ID, or false for the current domain
268 * @param int $flags Bitfield of CONN_* class constants (e.g. CONN_TRX_AUTOCOMMIT)
269 * @return MaintainableDBConnRef
270 */
271 public function getMaintenanceConnectionRef( $db, $groups = [], $domain = false, $flags = 0 );
272
273 /**
274 * Open a connection to the server given by the specified index
275 *
276 * The index must be an actual index into the array. If a connection to the server is
277 * already open and not considered an "in use" foreign connection, this simply returns it.
278 *
279 * Avoid using CONN_TRX_AUTOCOMMIT for databases with ATTR_DB_LEVEL_LOCKING (e.g. sqlite) in
280 * order to avoid deadlocks. ILoadBalancer::getServerAttributes() can be used to check
281 * such flags beforehand.
282 *
283 * If the caller uses $domain or sets CONN_TRX_AUTOCOMMIT in $flags, then it must also
284 * call ILoadBalancer::reuseConnection() on the handle when finished using it.
285 * In all other cases, this is not necessary, though not harmful either.
286 *
287 * @note This method throws DBAccessError if ILoadBalancer::disable() was called
288 *
289 * @param int $i Server index (does not support DB_MASTER/DB_REPLICA)
290 * @param string|bool $domain Domain ID, or false for the current domain
291 * @param int $flags Bitfield of CONN_* class constants (e.g. CONN_TRX_AUTOCOMMIT)
292 * @return Database|bool Returns false on errors
293 * @throws DBAccessError
294 */
295 public function openConnection( $i, $domain = false, $flags = 0 );
296
297 /**
298 * @return int
299 */
300 public function getWriterIndex();
301
302 /**
303 * Returns true if the specified index is a valid server index
304 *
305 * @param int $i
306 * @return bool
307 */
308 public function haveIndex( $i );
309
310 /**
311 * Returns true if the specified index is valid and has non-zero load
312 *
313 * @param int $i
314 * @return bool
315 */
316 public function isNonZeroLoad( $i );
317
318 /**
319 * Get the number of defined servers (not the number of open connections)
320 *
321 * @return int
322 */
323 public function getServerCount();
324
325 /**
326 * Get the host name or IP address of the server with the specified index
327 *
328 * @param int $i
329 * @return string Readable name if available or IP/host otherwise
330 */
331 public function getServerName( $i );
332
333 /**
334 * Return the server info structure for a given index, or false if the index is invalid.
335 * @param int $i
336 * @return array|bool
337 */
338 public function getServerInfo( $i );
339
340 /**
341 * Get DB type of the server with the specified index
342 *
343 * @param int $i
344 * @return string One of (mysql,postgres,sqlite,...) or "unknown" for bad indexes
345 * @since 1.30
346 */
347 public function getServerType( $i );
348
349 /**
350 * @param int $i Server index
351 * @return array (Database::ATTRIBUTE_* constant => value) for all such constants
352 * @since 1.31
353 */
354 public function getServerAttributes( $i );
355
356 /**
357 * Get the current master position for chronology control purposes
358 * @return DBMasterPos|bool Returns false if not applicable
359 */
360 public function getMasterPos();
361
362 /**
363 * Disable this load balancer. All connections are closed, and any attempt to
364 * open a new connection will result in a DBAccessError.
365 */
366 public function disable();
367
368 /**
369 * Close all open connections
370 */
371 public function closeAll();
372
373 /**
374 * Close a connection
375 *
376 * Using this function makes sure the LoadBalancer knows the connection is closed.
377 * If you use $conn->close() directly, the load balancer won't update its state.
378 *
379 * @param IDatabase $conn
380 */
381 public function closeConnection( IDatabase $conn );
382
383 /**
384 * Commit transactions on all open connections
385 * @param string $fname Caller name
386 * @throws DBExpectedError
387 */
388 public function commitAll( $fname = __METHOD__ );
389
390 /**
391 * Run pre-commit callbacks and defer execution of post-commit callbacks
392 *
393 * Use this only for mutli-database commits
394 *
395 * @return int Number of pre-commit callbacks run (since 1.32)
396 */
397 public function finalizeMasterChanges();
398
399 /**
400 * Perform all pre-commit checks for things like replication safety
401 *
402 * Use this only for mutli-database commits
403 *
404 * @param array $options Includes:
405 * - maxWriteDuration : max write query duration time in seconds
406 * @throws DBTransactionError
407 */
408 public function approveMasterChanges( array $options );
409
410 /**
411 * Flush any master transaction snapshots and set DBO_TRX (if DBO_DEFAULT is set)
412 *
413 * The DBO_TRX setting will be reverted to the default in each of these methods:
414 * - commitMasterChanges()
415 * - rollbackMasterChanges()
416 * - commitAll()
417 * This allows for custom transaction rounds from any outer transaction scope.
418 *
419 * @param string $fname
420 * @throws DBExpectedError
421 */
422 public function beginMasterChanges( $fname = __METHOD__ );
423
424 /**
425 * Issue COMMIT on all master connections where writes where done
426 * @param string $fname Caller name
427 * @throws DBExpectedError
428 */
429 public function commitMasterChanges( $fname = __METHOD__ );
430
431 /**
432 * Consume and run all pending post-COMMIT/ROLLBACK callbacks and commit dangling transactions
433 *
434 * @return Exception|null The first exception or null if there were none
435 */
436 public function runMasterTransactionIdleCallbacks();
437
438 /**
439 * Run all recurring post-COMMIT/ROLLBACK listener callbacks
440 *
441 * @return Exception|null The first exception or null if there were none
442 */
443 public function runMasterTransactionListenerCallbacks();
444
445 /**
446 * Issue ROLLBACK only on master, only if queries were done on connection
447 * @param string $fname Caller name
448 * @throws DBExpectedError
449 */
450 public function rollbackMasterChanges( $fname = __METHOD__ );
451
452 /**
453 * Commit all replica DB transactions so as to flush any REPEATABLE-READ or SSI snapshots
454 *
455 * @param string $fname Caller name
456 */
457 public function flushReplicaSnapshots( $fname = __METHOD__ );
458
459 /**
460 * Commit all master DB transactions so as to flush any REPEATABLE-READ or SSI snapshots
461 *
462 * An error will be thrown if a connection has pending writes or callbacks
463 *
464 * @param string $fname Caller name
465 */
466 public function flushMasterSnapshots( $fname = __METHOD__ );
467
468 /**
469 * @return bool Whether a master connection is already open
470 */
471 public function hasMasterConnection();
472
473 /**
474 * Whether there are pending changes or callbacks in a transaction by this thread
475 * @return bool
476 */
477 public function hasMasterChanges();
478
479 /**
480 * Get the timestamp of the latest write query done by this thread
481 * @return float|bool UNIX timestamp or false
482 */
483 public function lastMasterChangeTimestamp();
484
485 /**
486 * Check if this load balancer object had any recent or still
487 * pending writes issued against it by this PHP thread
488 *
489 * @param float $age How many seconds ago is "recent" [defaults to mWaitTimeout]
490 * @return bool
491 */
492 public function hasOrMadeRecentMasterChanges( $age = null );
493
494 /**
495 * Get the list of callers that have pending master changes
496 *
497 * @return string[] List of method names
498 */
499 public function pendingMasterChangeCallers();
500
501 /**
502 * @note This method will trigger a DB connection if not yet done
503 * @param string|bool $domain Domain ID, or false for the current domain
504 * @return bool Whether the database for generic connections this request is highly "lagged"
505 */
506 public function getLaggedReplicaMode( $domain = false );
507
508 /**
509 * Checks whether the database for generic connections this request was both:
510 * - a) Already choosen due to a prior connection attempt
511 * - b) Considered highly "lagged"
512 *
513 * @note This method will never cause a new DB connection
514 * @return bool
515 */
516 public function laggedReplicaUsed();
517
518 /**
519 * @note This method may trigger a DB connection if not yet done
520 * @param string|bool $domain Domain ID, or false for the current domain
521 * @param IDatabase|null $conn DB master connection; used to avoid loops [optional]
522 * @return string|bool Reason the master is read-only or false if it is not
523 */
524 public function getReadOnlyReason( $domain = false, IDatabase $conn = null );
525
526 /**
527 * Disables/enables lag checks
528 * @param null|bool $mode
529 * @return bool
530 */
531 public function allowLagged( $mode = null );
532
533 /**
534 * @return bool
535 */
536 public function pingAll();
537
538 /**
539 * Call a function with each open connection object
540 * @param callable $callback
541 * @param array $params
542 */
543 public function forEachOpenConnection( $callback, array $params = [] );
544
545 /**
546 * Call a function with each open connection object to a master
547 * @param callable $callback
548 * @param array $params
549 */
550 public function forEachOpenMasterConnection( $callback, array $params = [] );
551
552 /**
553 * Call a function with each open replica DB connection object
554 * @param callable $callback
555 * @param array $params
556 */
557 public function forEachOpenReplicaConnection( $callback, array $params = [] );
558
559 /**
560 * Get the hostname and lag time of the most-lagged replica DB
561 *
562 * This is useful for maintenance scripts that need to throttle their updates.
563 * May attempt to open connections to replica DBs on the default DB. If there is
564 * no lag, the maximum lag will be reported as -1.
565 *
566 * @param bool|string $domain Domain ID, or false for the default database
567 * @return array ( host, max lag, index of max lagged host )
568 */
569 public function getMaxLag( $domain = false );
570
571 /**
572 * Get an estimate of replication lag (in seconds) for each server
573 *
574 * Results are cached for a short time in memcached/process cache
575 *
576 * Values may be "false" if replication is too broken to estimate
577 *
578 * @param string|bool $domain
579 * @return int[] Map of (server index => float|int|bool)
580 */
581 public function getLagTimes( $domain = false );
582
583 /**
584 * Get the lag in seconds for a given connection, or zero if this load
585 * balancer does not have replication enabled.
586 *
587 * This should be used in preference to Database::getLag() in cases where
588 * replication may not be in use, since there is no way to determine if
589 * replication is in use at the connection level without running
590 * potentially restricted queries such as SHOW SLAVE STATUS. Using this
591 * function instead of Database::getLag() avoids a fatal error in this
592 * case on many installations.
593 *
594 * @param IDatabase $conn
595 * @return int|bool Returns false on error
596 */
597 public function safeGetLag( IDatabase $conn );
598
599 /**
600 * Wait for a replica DB to reach a specified master position
601 *
602 * This will connect to the master to get an accurate position if $pos is not given
603 *
604 * @param IDatabase $conn Replica DB
605 * @param DBMasterPos|bool $pos Master position; default: current position
606 * @param int $timeout Timeout in seconds [optional]
607 * @return bool Success
608 */
609 public function safeWaitForMasterPos( IDatabase $conn, $pos = false, $timeout = 10 );
610
611 /**
612 * Set a callback via IDatabase::setTransactionListener() on
613 * all current and future master connections of this load balancer
614 *
615 * @param string $name Callback name
616 * @param callable|null $callback
617 */
618 public function setTransactionListener( $name, callable $callback = null );
619
620 /**
621 * Set a new table prefix for the existing local domain ID for testing
622 *
623 * @param string $prefix
624 */
625 public function setDomainPrefix( $prefix );
626
627 /**
628 * Make certain table names use their own database, schema, and table prefix
629 * when passed into SQL queries pre-escaped and without a qualified database name
630 *
631 * For example, "user" can be converted to "myschema.mydbname.user" for convenience.
632 * Appearances like `user`, somedb.user, somedb.someschema.user will used literally.
633 *
634 * Calling this twice will completely clear any old table aliases. Also, note that
635 * callers are responsible for making sure the schemas and databases actually exist.
636 *
637 * @param array[] $aliases Map of (table => (dbname, schema, prefix) map)
638 */
639 public function setTableAliases( array $aliases );
640
641 /**
642 * Convert certain index names to alternative names before querying the DB
643 *
644 * Note that this applies to indexes regardless of the table they belong to.
645 *
646 * This can be employed when an index was renamed X => Y in code, but the new Y-named
647 * indexes were not yet built on all DBs. After all the Y-named ones are added by the DBA,
648 * the aliases can be removed, and then the old X-named indexes dropped.
649 *
650 * @param string[] $aliases
651 * @return mixed
652 * @since 1.31
653 */
654 public function setIndexAliases( array $aliases );
655 }